Following a time of mass avoidance in the aftermath of the dot-com bust, the U.S. IT work force is facing a shortage of people, according to the Commerce Department’s technology czar.
“The IT work force is not skilled enough and almost never can be skilled enough,” said Robert Cresanti, undersecretary of commerce for technology, in an exclusive interview with eWEEK editors. “There are not enough engineers with the appropriate skill sets.”
Cresanti said U.S. colleges and universities are not enrolling enough engineering students, resulting in a dearth of information technology professionals. In addition to boosting engineering enrollment, he urged opening the gates to more foreign workers, including H-1B holders.
(from eWeek, Tech Czar: More IT Workers Needed)
Let me get this straight: this genius thinks that if we increase the number of indentured servants we import to take existing IT jobs, thus reducing the demand for American IT workers, that this will encourage more Americans to go into IT.
Riiiight.
The number of American college students who major in IT is dropping because wages for people in IT are dropping and because the demand for Americans in IT is dropping. The wages in the IT field are dropping and the demand for Americans in IT is dropping because companies like Capital One and Circuit City prefer to hire lower-paid H1-B workers, who are essentially indentured servants. Increasing the number of H1-B visas, as this idiot Cresanti suggests, would make that situation worse, not better. What sensible person is going to spend a small fortune getting a technical degree when the pay is dropping and the jobs are being handed to imported indentured servants?
There are already numerous competent US IT people who are having trouble finding jobs because companies like Capital One and Circuit City give preferential hiring to H1-B workers. If we want to encourage more Americans to go into IT, we need to reduce or even eliminate the importation of H1-B workers. If we don’t (and I am sure we won’t), in a generation there won’t be any Americans in the IT field at all.
Do not misunderstand: this is not about race. It is not about immigration. It is about the future of the United States. The problem is not that people are willing to cross an ocean to work here, and the problem is not that those people have brown skin or have an accent. I strongly support immigration — let the best and brightest of the world come to the USA! Let them come here, and let them stay here, and become citizens. Immigration is what has made the US a great nation. H1-B workers are not immigrants — they come here, take jobs from Americans, and then they take that money and expertise and go home. Because they took IT jobs from Americans and drove down wages, fewer young Americans are willing to go into IT. Because there are fewer Americans in IT, the next batch of H1-B workers have jobs here waiting for them. It’s an expanding cycle, until there aren’t any American IT workers at all, and all of the money paid to IT workers goes overseas. Eventually, there won’t be any need for IT workers to come to the USA in the first place, because the jobs will have moved to India, or whatever other overpopulated third-world country rises to take India’s place thirty years from now. (If current trends hold out, that country will be China.)
It’s also worth pointing out, because sometimes people need to have things spelled out for them, that I have absolutely no animosity toward anyone who learns English and crosses an ocean to work here. I hope that I would be brave enough to do the same thing, in their situation. I have nothing but respect and admiration for people who would take such an enormous risk for a better life.