Blackmoor Vituperative

Microsoft has pledged to create rules on how it will deal with government complaints about Web sites and blogs hosted by the U.S. software giant.

Following concerns on how Microsoft pulled the blog of a critic of the Chinese government, Microsoft said that in the future it will only block access to diaries on its MSN Internet portal when it is presented with a court order or another legally binding decision.

But the blog will only be banned in that particular country.

“Going forward we will have a policy of removing access for the country where the blog was issued, but not outside that country,” Brad Smith, Microsoft ‘s chief counsel, said at a Microsoft conference.

Microsoft will find a technical solution to make sure the blog will still be viewable in other countries.

“We want to formulate a new framework and new principles. Principles need to emerge,” said Smith, adding that the need for clear guidelines became imperative after MSN took down the popular blog written by Zhao Jing last month.

Smith defended Microsoft’s decision by saying it had received an order from the information authorities in Shanghai, which Microsoft found to have legal authority to decide what can be published in China.

“That was one of the things that made us sit and think. [Now] it will be transparent what is happening and why,” Smith said.

Around 3.3 million bloggers in China publish their Web diaries on the Spaces pages of Microsoft’s MSN service.

Microsoft is not the only company struggling with China’s censorship rules.

Last month the country’s propaganda chiefs closed the outspoken supplement Freezing Point of respected newspaper China Youth Daily, and Web search leader Google announced restrictions on a new service for China to avoid confrontation with Beijing.

(from eWeek, Microsoft to Set Rules for Government Blog Complaints)

There is a very common misconception that obeying the law is right, and disobeying the law is wrong. From time to time, we in the USA need to get reminded that right and wrong have very little to do with the law, except by coincidence. All too often, the law is wrong. It was once illegal for slaves to flee their masters. It was once illegal for women to vote. It was once illegal to harbor a Jew from the German police. It was once illegal for a married couple living in Virginia to have oral sex (and that was only a year or so ago). It is still illegal to grow marijuana. In many states in the USA, it is legal for the state to seize your property and give it to someone else any time they want to.

Laws are made by people, and people are often wrong. Sometimes, those people aren’t merely wrong, but are actually evil, and the laws they make are equally so — and obeying an evil law is wrong. I think it’s only a matter of time before China reminds people in the USA of this unfortunate but inescapable fact.